If there’s one holiday treat that brings instant joy to my heart, it’s Soft Christmas Peppermints. Every December, our kitchen counter transforms into a peppermint-making station. I remember being barely tall enough to reach the mixing bowl, sneaking tastes of the creamy mint dough as my mom laughed. The scent of peppermint would float through the house, mingling with cinnamon candles and pine needles. Those little pastel swirls weren’t just candy—they were tradition.
As I’ve grown older, Soft Christmas Peppermints remain my go-to festive sweet. They’re easy to make, adorable to gift, and honestly, impossible to resist. Whether you’re crafting gift boxes, filling candy jars, or just need a soft mint to cap off a heavy Christmas dinner, these dreamy, melt-in-your-mouth treats hit the spot. In this article, we’ll walk through everything you need to know: what makes Soft Christmas Peppermints so irresistible, how to make them perfect every time, the secret behind their texture, and creative ways to serve them.
Let’s bring that holiday cheer into your kitchen—one soft peppermint at a time.
What Makes Soft Christmas Peppermints Irresistible
The Flavor That Defines a Season
Soft Christmas Peppermints capture more than just a minty taste. They hold nostalgia, comfort, and that signature cool-sweet sensation that instantly says holidays are here. Unlike hard peppermint sticks or store-bought mints, Soft Christmas Peppermints are creamy and gentle. They melt on your tongue without any effort. It’s that dreamy texture combined with pure peppermint oil that makes them so memorable.
Their flavor is simple, yet powerful. A few drops of real peppermint extract go a long way. And when blended into a silky base of powdered sugar and cream cheese, you get a candy that feels like a cloud. Each bite delivers a soft peppermint whisper, not a loud menthol blast. That balance is what makes Soft Christmas Peppermints better than anything you’ll grab in a checkout aisle.
Soft Christmas Peppermints
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Beat cream cheese and butter in a mixing bowl until smooth.
- Add peppermint extract and mix to combine.
- Gradually add powdered sugar until a soft dough forms.
- Divide and add food coloring if desired. Mix until even.
- Roll into small balls and flatten with a fork or mold into shapes.
- Let dry on a parchment-lined tray for 2–4 hours. Store in airtight container.
Nutrition
Notes
Tried this recipe?
Let us know how it was!The Allure of Homemade vs Store-Bought
There’s no comparison between homemade Soft Christmas Peppermints and commercial versions. Store-bought mints often include preservatives and artificial texture enhancers that give them a chalky, firm bite. But when you make these at home, you control every detail—starting with quality ingredients and ending with how soft you want them.
Homemade Soft Christmas Peppermints offer customization. Want a little food coloring for a festive swirl? Add a drop. Prefer organic peppermint extract or dairy-free cream cheese? Totally doable. This makes them great for kids’ parties, gifting, or even wedding showers. A batch can be made in under an hour and shaped with festive cookie cutters, adding joy to every candy bowl.
And let’s not forget cost. For the price of one bag of store-bought peppermints, you can whip up triple the amount at home with fresher taste and softer texture. Plus, when placed next to other classics like peppermint brownie cookies or crumbl Christmas sugar cookies, your homemade mints stand out every time.
Texture Is Everything in Soft Christmas Peppermints
If flavor is the soul of a good peppermint, texture is the heart. What sets Soft Christmas Peppermints apart is their cloud-like softness that doesn’t stick to your teeth. This comes from the right balance of powdered sugar and cream cheese. Too little sugar, and they’re sticky. Too much, and they become crumbly.
Achieving that perfect softness takes patience and precision. The dough should be firm enough to roll but soft enough to dent with a finger. Once shaped, they should sit uncovered to dry slightly on the outside while remaining pillowy inside. It’s this balance that transforms them from a basic mint into a beloved tradition.
The texture also changes with temperature. Refrigerated Soft Christmas Peppermints firm up just a little, which makes them excellent for gifting in warmer climates. Let them sit out for 10 minutes, and they’re back to melt-in-your-mouth mode. That’s the beauty of homemade—they adapt.
Ideal Pairings and Presentation
You don’t just toss Soft Christmas Peppermints into a bowl and call it a day—though no judgment if you do. These mints are beautifully versatile. Pair them with chocolate thumbprint cookies for a mint-chocolate tray. Or drop one into a cup of hot cocoa to add a minty burst. Guests will be surprised and delighted.
For gifting, wrap them in mini parchment squares or place them in mini cupcake liners. You can color-code them—red for cinnamon, green for peppermint, white for vanilla mint. Add a rustic ribbon, and your candy box becomes a heartfelt present. These little details make Soft Christmas Peppermints the star of any dessert spread.
Their dainty size also makes them perfect for dessert boards. Mix them among Santa macarons and frosted Christmas brownies for a festive variety that looks store-bought but feels homemade.
How to Make Soft Christmas Peppermints at Home
Essential Ingredients for Perfect Peppermints
Creating Soft Christmas Peppermints at home is much easier than you might think. You only need a few ingredients, most of which are pantry staples. The hero? Full-fat cream cheese. Its rich, smooth texture gives the candy its signature softness. Blend it with pure peppermint extract and high-quality powdered sugar, and you’re already halfway to peppermint heaven.
Start with:
- Cream cheese (room temperature)
- Butter (for added richness)
- Peppermint extract (not imitation!)
- Powdered sugar (sifted for smoothness)
- Food coloring (optional, for festive flair)
What you won’t need are eggs, ovens, or candy thermometers. This no-bake treat is as stress-free as holiday baking gets. That’s why Soft Christmas Peppermints are perfect for last-minute gatherings or edible gifts when time is tight.
Step-by-Step Instructions for Foolproof Results
- Cream the base: Beat cream cheese and butter together until completely smooth.
- Flavor it: Add peppermint extract slowly—start small, as it’s powerful.
- Add sugar: Gradually mix in powdered sugar until a soft, non-sticky dough forms.
- Color it: Divide and color dough if desired—classic red, green, or leave white.
- Shape and rest: Roll into small balls or press into silicone molds, then let them dry slightly before storing.
These steps make a batch that rivals any candy shop’s offering. They’re so soft that they practically dissolve on your tongue. Bonus tip: Store them in an airtight container with parchment between layers. They’ll keep their softness for days.
Pairing them with classic Christmas toffee or raspberry linzer cookies makes for a stunning dessert spread.
Secrets to Customizing Soft Christmas Peppermints
Color, Flavor, and Shape Variations
One of the most exciting parts of making Soft Christmas Peppermints is customizing them. Start with food coloring. Red, green, and white are traditional, but swirl them together for a marbled effect. You can also mold them into stars, trees, or hearts using mini cutters or silicone molds.
Flavor variations are endless. While peppermint is the classic, try adding a touch of vanilla, cinnamon, or almond for something new. Just be sure to test small batches—some extracts can overpower the softness of the mint profile.
Mix-ins like crushed candy canes or mini chocolate chips add texture. Just keep the pieces small to preserve that melt-in-your-mouth effect. These personalized touches make Soft Christmas Peppermints ideal for themed events or dessert tables.
Want to go even fancier? Dip one side in white chocolate and sprinkle with edible glitter. Suddenly your mints go from cozy to classy, perfect next to gingerbread crinkle cookies or Debbie Christmas tree cake truffles.
Make-Ahead and Freezer Friendly
Soft Christmas Peppermints store surprisingly well. Once dried slightly on the outside, you can refrigerate them for up to two weeks. Freeze them in airtight containers for up to three months. Just thaw at room temperature before serving, and they’ll be just as soft and flavorful.
To avoid sticking, layer with parchment paper. For gifting, freeze them in advance and pop them into treat bags when needed. This flexibility means you can prep early and enjoy your holidays stress-free.
Soft Christmas Peppermints are the ultimate make-ahead treat. You can even make the dough days in advance, refrigerate it, and roll or mold it when you have time. Try pairing a frozen batch with Christmas popcorn balls for a nostalgic, kid-friendly treat box.
Serving, Gifting & Displaying Soft Christmas Peppermints
Creative Ways to Serve and Enjoy
Soft Christmas Peppermints are the little black dress of holiday desserts—they go with everything. Serve them with coffee after dinner, mix them into a festive cookie tray, or include them in a DIY hot cocoa bar. Their smooth texture balances rich desserts like fudgy red velvet crinkle cookies or easy reindeer cupcakes.
You can also crush them and sprinkle over whipped cream-topped pies or use them to rim peppermint martini glasses. If you’re hosting, place a few at each setting with a handwritten name tag for an edible place card guests will love.
At kids’ parties, have little ones roll the dough into balls and press with a fork to flatten—it’s a fun, edible craft. No matter the occasion, Soft Christmas Peppermints bring sweetness and creativity.
Holiday Gifting That Wows
When it comes to edible gifts, nothing beats the charm of Soft Christmas Peppermints. Package them in mason jars with a festive ribbon or layer them in clear boxes with cookie assortments. They travel well, keep their flavor, and show effort without stress.
Add a custom label with your family name or the year. Or create a peppermint sampler alongside white chocolate peppermint cookies and cheesy pull-apart Christmas tree bread for a sweet and savory twist.
Want something extra special? Pair the mints with a handwritten holiday card or a tiny ornament. These thoughtful touches elevate simple candy into a meaningful gift that gets remembered. That’s the magic of Soft Christmas Peppermints—delightfully personal, beautifully simple.
Wrap-Up
Soft Christmas Peppermints are more than just candy—they’re tradition, comfort, and creativity all rolled into one. Whether you’re crafting them with kids, adding sparkle to your dessert table, or giving them as heartfelt gifts, they never disappoint. With endless customization, easy prep, and timeless flavor, they deserve a place in every holiday kitchen. Start with the basics, add your personal flair, and enjoy every cool, creamy bite. Soft Christmas Peppermints are the kind of treat you’ll want to make (and eat) year after year.
FAQ’s
How do you keep Soft Christmas Peppermints soft after storing?
Store them in airtight containers with parchment between layers. Room temperature works well for 3–5 days. For longer storage, refrigerate them.
Can I use natural peppermint extract?
Absolutely. Natural extracts give a stronger, purer flavor to your Soft Christmas Peppermints. Start with a smaller amount and adjust as needed.
Are Soft Christmas Peppermints gluten-free?
Yes! They contain no flour or gluten-based ingredients, making them naturally gluten-free and safe for most diets.
Can I freeze Soft Christmas Peppermints?
Yes. Freeze in a single layer in airtight containers. Thaw at room temperature before serving—they’ll retain their texture.
